Skip to Content Facebook Feature Image

US-North Korean deals often made away from negotiating table

News

US-North Korean deals often made away from negotiating table
News

News

US-North Korean deals often made away from negotiating table

2019-02-23 22:08 Last Updated At:22:20

Beware of humor gone awry. Don't be afraid to show emotion. Watch those offhanded one-liners.

At the negotiating table, it can be difficult to get North Korean negotiators off their scripted talking points. Sometimes deals are best sealed while on a Pyongyang subway ride, a stroll outside or even during fits of anger.

No matter what President Donald Trump and North Korea's Kim Jong Un may agree to at their Vietnam summit this coming week, the follow-up to those talks will require the kind of laborious discussions that have marked four major sets of negotiating sessions between the two sides over the past quarter-century.

In this Sept. 13, 2018, file photo, a North Korean subway officer stands next to a train in a subway station in Pyongyang, North Korea. At the negotiating table, it can be difficult to get the North Koreans off their scripted talking points. (AP PhotoKin Cheung, file)

In this Sept. 13, 2018, file photo, a North Korean subway officer stands next to a train in a subway station in Pyongyang, North Korea. At the negotiating table, it can be difficult to get the North Koreans off their scripted talking points. (AP PhotoKin Cheung, file)

Former U.S. diplomats who have spent years in such talks say their North Korean counterparts are always prepared and keen to sniff out anything that seems like a U.S. precondition. They say the North Koreans can launch into anti-American diatribes one minute, then courteously agree to concessions — once they're certain they've gotten all they can.

Bob Carlin, who took part in talks during the Clinton administration, recalled that at the end of one particularly difficult day of negotiations, the chief North Korean balked at one item that had been agreed upon earlier.

"I popped my cork," Carlin said. "This was not an act. I was so angry that he would do this to me."

FILE - In this March 22, 2007, file photo, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Christopher Hill, right, walks through a hotel lobby with Victor Cha, the U.S. National Security Council's director for Asian Affairs, before heading to six-party talks on North Korea's nuclear program, in Beijing. At the negotiating table, it can be difficult to get the North Koreans off their scripted talking points.  (AP PhotoGreg Baker, File)

FILE - In this March 22, 2007, file photo, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Christopher Hill, right, walks through a hotel lobby with Victor Cha, the U.S. National Security Council's director for Asian Affairs, before heading to six-party talks on North Korea's nuclear program, in Beijing. At the negotiating table, it can be difficult to get the North Koreans off their scripted talking points. (AP PhotoGreg Baker, File)

When the North Korean saw Carlin's flash of anger, he quickly backed down and agreed to what had already been negotiated. The North Korean negotiator apparently just wanted to be able to go back to his superiors and say that he had pushed the Americans as far as he could.

"I learned something important," Carlin said. "If they really go over the line and make me mad, don't sit back and try to be nice. Let them know because they don't want things to fall apart."

In another session, it was the lead North Korean negotiator who got miffed. Carlin, who has traveled to North Korea more than 30 times, said one of the U.S. negotiators wondered aloud when North Korea was going to "join the civilized world."

"The temperature in the room dropped below freezing" and the top North Korean scolded the U.S. negotiator, Carlin said. "It's the type of thing that Americans say without thinking and the North Koreans don't accept."

Victor Cha, a U.S. diplomat who helped negotiate a deal with North Korea in the 1990s, said sometimes the Americans want success so badly that they get caught in negotiation traps choreographed by the North Koreans.

"One of their classic negotiation loops is this end-of-war declaration," Cha said. The idea is that the U.S. declares an end to the Korean War, which ended without a peace treaty. Then, the North Koreans demand the U.S. lift sanctions on them because the war is over. "No," Cha said. "The sanctions are on them for proliferation behavior and human rights abuses. They improve those things, then you lift some comparable sanctions."

Former New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson, who was the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations during the Clinton administration, has been a frequent mediator with North Korea since the 1990s. He has visited at least eight times, sometimes acting independently to seek the release of American detainees.

Richardson said he was talking to a North Korean official on the Pyongyang subway in 1996 when he finally persuaded him to release Evan Hunziker, an American who had illegally entered the communist country by swimming, while drunk, across the Yalu River from China.

"About 75 percent of the talking points are anti-American ranting," Richardson said. "So, you've got to make deals with them outside of the negotiating table — either at a meal, or walking or in the subway as I did with Hunziker."

Richardson said humor works sometimes, but American negotiators need to use it carefully. As a joke, Richardson said he once inquired about Hunziker's condition in detention, specifically if he still "had his fingernails."

"I started smiling," Richardson said. "The North Korean looked at me. I thought he was going to kill me. And then he started laughing. They're not used to humor. They're very formal."

On the flip side, Richardson said it was he who didn't know whether the North Koreans were joking when they asked to be reimbursed for the cost of ammunition they used to shoot at an American helicopter pilot in 1994.

Army pilot Bobby Hall's helicopter was hit by North Korean air defenses after he strayed across the border, forcing him into an emergency landing. His co-pilot later died from his injuries.

"They said 'Your pilot violated North Korean air space and so we had to shoot it down and you have to pay for it,'" Richardson said. "I said 'I'm not going to do that. That's ridiculous.' But they were very serious."

Stephen Biegun, the Trump administration's point man on North Korea, said the United States is trying to find better ways to talk with its North Korean counterparts.

"I am not kidding when I say it is difficult for us to communicate with each other," Biegun said in a recent speech at Stanford University.

"We are located in very different parts of the world with very different histories. We have dramatically different views on individual rights and on human rights. ... We also have no trade of any sort, no diplomatic relations and virtually no ability to communicate directly with one another."

Despite that, the two sides for months have been engaged in talks and exchanging letters — messages of trust and confidence to lubricate the process.

Trump has been effusive about his exchanges from Kim.

He told a political rally in West Virginia last fall: "He wrote me beautiful letters and they're great letters. We fell in love."

Follow all of AP's summit coverage at https://apnews.com/Trump-KimSummit

Next Article

US Election 2024-The Daily Rundown

2024-04-25 20:20 Last Updated At:20:30

Here’s a rundown of the AP’s latest Election 2024 coverage plans, including live video and text plans, our explanatory journalism and highlights from previous cycles. Candidate schedules are included when available. All times are EDT.

You can find US Election 2024-The Daily Rundown in your CMS or in AP Newsroom.

For up-to-the-minute information on AP’s coverage, visit AP Newsroom’s Coverage Plan. Find our election coverage in the U.S. Elections hub in AP Newsroom.

To sign up for our Politics Advisory, delivered afternoons Monday through Friday to your inbox, click here.

SUPREME COURT-TRUMP-CAPITOL RIOT — AP Explains the latest election subversion case before the Supreme Court: Whether Donald Trump is immune from prosecution in a case charging him with plotting to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election. Includes an AP reporter debrief from last week's hearing on whether federal prosecutors went too far in bringing obstruction charges against hundreds of participants in the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot. Newsroom Ready and Consumer Ready edits sent on April 16.

ELECTION 2024-US TERRITORIES — What to know about living in U.S. territories ahead of the 2024 election. Newsroom Ready and Consumer Ready edits.

7 a.m. — Live US Network Pool Cameras and Live AP Cameras outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington where justices are hearing arguments on presidential immunity. Live cameras on protesters amid supporters outside, along with live reaction from lawyers. Audio livestream also booked.

7 a.m. — Live AP Camera coverage outside of Trump Tower in New York is planned.

8:30 a.m. — Live NY Trump Pool coverage outside of the courthouse in New York is planned.

ELECTION 2024-PENNSYLVANIA-HALEY — When Nikki Haley suspended her presidential campaign, she refused to endorse Donald Trump as the last remaining major candidate for the 2024 Republican nomination — and so did some of her supporters in Pennsylvania. SENT: 480 words, photo.

BIDEN-FUNDRAISER — President Joe Biden is scheduled to attend a campaign fundraiser in Irvington, New York, on Thursday night. Hosts include Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta-Jones. AP does not expect this event to be open to the media, but it will be traveling with the president and it will provide video edits and Live coverage if there is breaking news.

ELECTION 2024-DECISION NOTES-PUERTO RICO — Puerto Rico will hold a Democratic presidential primary Sunday, the only opportunity for Democrats on the island to officially weigh in on the race for the White House. Sent April 24: 970 words, photos.

SUPREME COURT-TRUMP-CAPITOL RIOT — Supreme Court justices seem to agree on a basic truth about the American system of government: No one is above the law, not even the president. But former President Donald Trump and his legal team are putting that truth to the test when the high court takes up Trump’s bid to avoid prosecution over his efforts to overturn his 2020 election loss to President Joe Biden. SENT: 780 words, photo. UPCOMING: 1,100 words after 10 a.m. arguments. With TRUMP-CAPITOL RIOT-LISTENERS’ GUIDE — What to listen for during Supreme Court arguments on Trump and presidential immunity. Sent April 24.

TRUMP-HUSH MONEY — A judge is weighing whether to hold Donald Trump in contempt of court for what prosecutors say have been repeated violations of the gag order in his hush money criminal trial. Jurors are also expected to hear more testimony from David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer, about the tabloid’s involvement in a scheme to benefit Trump. SENT: 650 words, photos. UPCOMING: 990 words after trial resumes at 9:30 a.m.

BIDEN — President Biden heads to upstate New York to tout his administration’s efforts to promote computer chip manufacturing in the U.S. SENT: 760 words, photos. UPCOMING: Speech at 2 p.m. Video edits and Live planned.

FAKE ELECTORS-INDICTMENT-ARIZONA — An Arizona grand jury has indicted former President Donald Trump ’s chief of staff Mark Meadows, lawyer Rudy Giuliani and 16 others for their efforts to use so-called fake electors to try to overturn Trump’s loss to Joe Biden in the 2020 presidential election. SENT: 1,200 words, photos, audio. With ELECTION 2020-MICHIGAN-FAKE ELECTORS — Investigator said Trump, allies were uncharged co-conspirators in plot to overturn Michigan election.

ELECTION 2024-BIDEN-TIKTOK — President Joe Biden’s signing of legislation that could ban TikTok in the U.S. runs counter to his campaign’s embrace of the platform and outreach to influencers. The president is also facing criticism from some avid users of the app. SENT: 1,300 words, photos.

ELECTION-2024-BIDEN-UNION — President Joe Biden picked up the endorsement of North America’s Building Trades Unions where the president and his allies set out to dismantle Republican Donald Trump’s reputation as a successful real estate developer. SENT: 380 words, photos, audio.

Sun., April 28 — Puerto Rico Democratic presidential primary.

May 7 — Indiana presidential primary.

May 14 — Maryland presidential primary, Nebraska presidential primary and West Virginia presidential primary.

May 21 — California 20th Congressional District special election, Kentucky presidential primary, Oregon presidential primary.

May 23 — Idaho Democratic Caucuses.

For coverage and planning questions, the Nerve Center can be reached at +1 800 845 8450 (ext. 1600). For access to AP Newsroom and other technical issues, contact apcustomersupport@ap.org or call +1 844 777 2006.

President Joe Biden speaks before signing a $95 billion Ukraine aid package that also includes support for Israel, Taiwan, and other allies, in the State Dining Room of the White House, Wednesday, April 24, 2024, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

President Joe Biden speaks before signing a $95 billion Ukraine aid package that also includes support for Israel, Taiwan, and other allies, in the State Dining Room of the White House, Wednesday, April 24, 2024, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

Recommended Articles