A look at the revived allegations against Justice Kavanaugh

News

A look at the revived allegations against Justice Kavanaugh

2019-09-17 04:11 Last Updated At：04:20

A new claim of decades-old sexual impropriety by Justice Brett Kavanaugh is rekindling the controversy that nearly derailed his confirmation to the Supreme Court last year. The allegation was unearthed by two New York Times reporters in their research for a book about the Kavanaugh confirmation. The book says the FBI was made aware of but did not investigate the incident, purported to take place when Kavanaugh was a Yale University student in the 1980s.

Kavanaugh declined to comment through the court's press office, but in Senate testimony last year, he flatly denied other misconduct claims, including an allegation of sexual assault during his high school years made by Christine Blasey Ford and a separate episode at Yale involving college classmate Deborah Ramirez.

The new allegation has elicited calls from some Democratic presidential contenders for Kavanaugh's impeachment and strong defenses of Kavanaugh from leading Republicans, including the man who appointed him to the high court, President Donald Trump.

Some questions and answers about the situation:

Q. What are the new allegations?

A. Times reporters Robin Pogebrin and Kate Kelly wrote in an essay in Sunday's newspaper drawn from their new book, "The Education of Brett Kavanaugh: An Investigation," that a classmate saw Kavanaugh expose himself to a female student at a drunken dorm party in Kavanaugh's freshman year. The essay said the classmate notified senators and the FBI about the incident, but the FBI did not investigate. The allegation is similar to the one Ramirez made last year, that Kavanaugh had exposed himself to her at another freshman-year party.

The Times did not initially report that the unidentified woman declined to be interviewed, and that her friends say she doesn't recall it. Those details were later appended to the piece. The classmate who said he saw the episode was identified as Max Stier, who later became a law clerk at the Supreme Court and now runs a non-partisan government reform group in Washington. Stier also once worked for the law firm Williams and Connolly when it was representing President Bill Clinton in the investigation of his affair with White House intern Monica Lewinsky. Kavanaugh worked for independent counsel Kenneth Starr at the time. Some conservatives were livid that the Times did not include Stier's law-firm affiliation.

Q. Didn't the FBI investigate allegations of sexual misconduct against Kavanaugh before the Senate voted to confirm him?

A. Yes, but Stier was never interviewed, Pogebrin and Kelly wrote. And the FBI had been given Stier's name by Sen. Chris Coons, D-Del., a Judiciary Committee member, according to an Oct. 2 letter obtained by The Associated Press. Coons did not make the matter public at the time because Stier asked for confidentiality and because he assumed the FBI would investigate the claim, according to a person familiar with Coons' thinking. The name is blacked out in AP's copy, but the person confirmed that the letter mentioned Stier by name. Kavanaugh was confirmed Oct. 6. Ramirez's lawyers provided the FBI the names of roughly 20 people, but few if any were ever interviewed. FBI Director Christopher Wray testified last year that the investigation was "limited in scope."

Q. What has Kavanaugh said about sexual misconduct allegations?

A. Kavanaugh has flatly denied Ford's and Ramirez's sexual misconduct allegations. "I've never sexually assaulted anyone. Not in high school, not in college, not ever," he said in his charged statement to the Senate Judiciary Committee following Ford's testimony. He said allegations of sexual assault must always be taken seriously. "Those that make allegations always deserve to be heard," Kavanaugh said. But he said the accused "also deserves to be heard."

Q. How have Democrats and Republicans reacted to the new allegation?

A. Predictably, with an eye to their parties' bases. Leading Democratic presidential candidates have demanded that Kavanaugh be investigated or impeached. "Like the man who appointed him, Kavanaugh should be impeached," Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren said. Republicans, including Trump, have argued that the Times story is an effort by the media to smear Kavanaugh's record. Kavanaugh is an "innocent man who has been treated HORRIBLY," Trump tweeted, suggesting the justice should "start suing people for libel, or the Justice Department should come to his rescue."

Q. Are impeachment and removal from office realistic possibilities?

A. Not in this universe. There is no chance that the requisite two-thirds of the Republican-controlled Senate would currently vote to remove Kavanaugh from office, even if the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives were to impeach him. And it's far from clear that there is any political will in the House to impeach Kavanaugh, given the time and attention it would demand, Democrats' ongoing investigations of Trump and their lack of consensus about a formal impeachment process for the president. "Frankly we are concentrating our resources on determining whether to impeach the president," Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, said Monday on WNYC's "The Brian Lehrer Show."

Q. Did the controversy affect Kavanaugh's first year on the court?

A. The uproar over Kavanaugh's nomination and confirmation seemed to have an effect both on the court and the new justice. Kavanaugh refrained from speaking engagements, other than an appearance at a conference of judges and lawyers in Milwaukee. (The conservative Federalist Society has said Kavanaugh will speak in November at a dinner attended by roughly 2,000 people.) The justices seemed intent on keeping the year as low-key as possible, temporarily avoiding several high-profile cases on immigration and abortion, among other issues. In the aftermath of the controversy, Chief Justice John Roberts and other justices have tried to rebut views of the court as a political institution similar to elected branches of government.

Kavanaugh's standing among the justices appears unaffected by the controversy that preceded his confirmation. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has called him a hard worker and, more than once, noted that his first group of four law clerks was all women. In March, Justice Sonia Sotomayor responded to a questioner who asked how he could "continue to respect the integrity of the Supreme Court" with Kavanaugh as a justice. Whether the allegations are true or not, Sotomayor said, "In the end, we have to rely on being judged not by what we've done, but what we're going to do. He's my colleague now and I live each day, sometimes not liking the vote, sometimes liking it, but still waiting to see what he turns out to be as a justice because that's what I will have to judge him on."

Associated Press writers Mary Clare Jalonick, Juana Summers and Eric Tucker contributed to this report.

New storms pummel the South as a week of deadly weather marches on

2024-05-09 22:16 Last Updated At：22:21

COLUMBIA, Tenn. (AP) — A wave of dangerous storms began washing over parts of the South early Thursday, a day after severe weather with damaging tornadoes and large hail killed at least three people in the region.

A heavy line of storms swept into Atlanta near the end of the morning rush hour. Busy hub airports in Atlanta and Charlotte, North Carolina, reported delays Thursday morning. Tornado warnings were issued for parts of Tennessee and Alabama.

The storms continue a streak of torrential rains and tornadoes this week from the Plains to the Midwest and, now, the Southeast. At least four people have died since Monday. The weather comes on the heels of a stormy April in which the U.S. had 300 confirmed tornadoes, the second-most on record for the month and the most since 2011.

Storms had already left more than a quarter-million customers without power Thursday in North Carolina, Tennessee, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama and Missouri, according to PowerOutage.us.

A storm Wednesday in northeastern Tennessee damaged homes, injured people, toppled power lines and trees, and killed a 22-year-old man in a car in Claiborne County, north of Knoxville, officials said. A second person was killed south of Nashville in Columbia, the Maury County seat, where officials said a tornado had likely touched down and homes were blown off their foundations.

Bob Booth had just gotten home to Columbia from Georgia and was sitting down to watch television when he heard a “crazy racket.”

“I get up and look out, and it was all hell breaking loose outside,” Booth said. “Then the top half of one of my trees goes down across the road.”

Booth said he was told it would be a while before his power was restored. One neighbor, he said, lost all trees except one that would have destroyed his house: “So that guy is blessed."

Schools were closed Thursday in several Tennessee counties. Some districts north of Atlanta canceled in-person classes or delayed start times because of storm damage overnight that included fallen trees on houses and vehicles around Clarkesville. No injuries were reported there.

“We’re just trying to clean up right now and wait for the next round,” said Lynn Smith, director of the Habersham County Emergency Management Agency.

Torrential rains led to a flash flood emergency and water rescues northeast of Nashville. The Federal Aviation Administration issued a temporary ground stop at Nashville's main airport, and the weather service issued a tornado emergency, its highest alert level, for nearby areas.

In North Carolina, a state of emergency was declared Wednesday night for Gaston County, west of Charlotte, after a storm that toppled power lines and trees, including one that landed on a car. One person in the car was killed, and another was taken to a hospital, officials said.

The storms followed heavy rain, strong winds, hail and tornadoes in parts of the central U.S. on Monday, including a twister that ripped through an Oklahoma town and killed one person. On Tuesday, the Midwest took the brunt of the bad weather. Tornadoes touched down in parts of Michigan, Ohio and Indiana, according to the weather service.

Michigan's Kalamazoo area was hard hit as a FedEx facility was ripped apart, with downed power lines trapping about 50 people.

Tornadoes were also confirmed near Pittsburgh, in central Arkansas and in northern West Virginia. The West Virginia twister was at least the 11th tornado this year in the state, which sees two tornadoes in an average year.

Both the Plains and Midwest have been hammered by tornadoes this spring.

Cappelletti and White reported from Detroit. Associated Press journalists around the country contributed to this report, including Jeff Amy, Joey Cappelletti, Ed White, Rio Yamat, Heather Hollingsworth, Colleen Slevin, Jim Salter, Kathy McCormack, Sarah Brumfield, Beatrice Dupuy, Alexa St. John, Adrian Sainz, John Raby and Lisa Baumann.

The Associated Press’ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.