Skip to Content Facebook Feature Image

Nepal's sexual minorities say progress in rights has stalled

News

Nepal's sexual minorities say progress in rights has stalled
News

News

Nepal's sexual minorities say progress in rights has stalled

2019-09-18 14:57 Last Updated At:15:00

Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. Even citizenship certificates and passports now allow a "non-male, non-female" category.

But same-sex couples such as Niraj Sunwar and Aashik Lama say progress has stalled since the constitution was adopted.

More Images
In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama smokes hookah at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. Even citizenship certificates and passports now allow a "non-male, non-female" category.

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, participants dance at a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

"We want to be lawfully wedded in a government office and have a legal certificate so we can openly live the life we want," Lama said. "We want to adopt a baby and start a family life."

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant holds a rainbow flag and marches in a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

"Nepal opened the way and other countries are following, but it has stalled here," said Manisha Dhakal, executive director of the Blue Diamond Society, an LGBT rights group. "Parliament has no commitment; it just doesn't want to do it."

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, a half male and half female picture greets customers at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Meghna Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

Under a new citizenship bill being prepared in parliament, transgender people seeking to change their status would be required to show medical proof, but the bill does not clarify what kind, Dhakal said.

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama sits for a photograph as she speaks with the Associated Press at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

Nepal's constitution was ahead of its time not just at home but also in South Asia.

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant stands beside a rainbow flag before a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

If the rights were granted as they appear in the constitution, Nepal would be head of almost every country in all of Asia. Taiwan in May became the first place in the region to legalize same-sex marriage.

Sunwar, 23, and Lama, 28, are still waiting for the day when they can legally marry. Lama also hopes to adopt a child, which isn't possible because no laws currently allow it.

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama smokes hookah at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama smokes hookah at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

"We want to be lawfully wedded in a government office and have a legal certificate so we can openly live the life we want," Lama said. "We want to adopt a baby and start a family life."

Such rights were enshrined in the constitution, which was introduced after the abolition of Nepal's centuries-old monarchy, because of a 2008 Supreme Court ruling that outlawed all discrimination against sexual minorities. LGBT activists, however, say politicians have failed to write new laws that reflect their rights.

Even worse, a Civil Code that was passed through parliament and came into force last year has moved things backward by clearly stating that marriage is a union between a man and a woman.

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, participants dance at a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, participants dance at a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

"Nepal opened the way and other countries are following, but it has stalled here," said Manisha Dhakal, executive director of the Blue Diamond Society, an LGBT rights group. "Parliament has no commitment; it just doesn't want to do it."

In addition to banning sexual discrimination, the new constitution provides special privileges to minority groups, including a reserved number of government jobs and educational positions. The LGBT community has been defined as a minority, but receives no such reserved positions.

"Though the constitution says clearly there should be no discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, there are no laws to support it," said Pinky Gurung, an LGBT rights activist.

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant holds a rainbow flag and marches in a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant holds a rainbow flag and marches in a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

Under a new citizenship bill being prepared in parliament, transgender people seeking to change their status would be required to show medical proof, but the bill does not clarify what kind, Dhakal said.

"A provision requiring us to get examined physically violates our privacy," she said, also noting that sex change surgery is currently unavailable in Nepal and unaffordable for most transgender people.

She said activists are planning to go to court to demand equal rights, and then take the issue to international rights groups to pressure the government.

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, a half male and half female picture greets customers at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Meghna Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, a half male and half female picture greets customers at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Meghna Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

Nepal's constitution was ahead of its time not just at home but also in South Asia.

In India, homosexuality wasn't decriminalized until last year when the Supreme Court declared British-era laws unconstitutional. Tiny Bhutan's parliament recently repealed provisions that made "unnatural sex" illegal.

Meanwhile in Bangladesh and Pakistan, both Muslim-majority nations, gay relationships remain illegal, and gay rights activists routinely face discrimination.

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama sits for a photograph as she speaks with the Associated Press at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 23, 2019, photo, Meghna Lama sits for a photograph as she speaks with the Associated Press at Tiffany restaurant in Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal. For Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine. From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

If the rights were granted as they appear in the constitution, Nepal would be head of almost every country in all of Asia. Taiwan in May became the first place in the region to legalize same-sex marriage.

There is no accurate number for the size of Nepal's LGBT community. The next census, held every 10 years, is planned for 2021, and Gurung said they are demanding that the number of LGBT people be counted.

Because there is no census data, there are no quotas for jobs, educational positions or health care slots for the LGBT community. And activists say discrimination against the LGBT community in Nepal is still all too common in everyday life.

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant stands beside a rainbow flag before a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

In this Aug. 16, 2019, photo, a participant stands beside a rainbow flag before a gay pride parade in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal seized the lead in equal rights for sexual minorities in South Asia four years ago with a new constitution that forbids all discrimination based on sexual orientation. But activists say progress in equal rights has stalled since the constitution was adopted. (AP PhotoNiranjan Shrestha)

"Because there is no same-sex marriage provision in Nepal, we have been facing difficulties in society," Sunwar said. "When we walk in the street together, our neighbors always look down on us because two men are living together as a couple."

They have been living together for two years, but only told their parents a few months ago.

For Meghna Lama, who has been running Pink Tiffany, the first LGBT-friendly restaurant in the heart of Kathmandu's tourist district, overcoming challenges has become routine.

From convincing building owners to facing harassment from the authorities and customers, she has come a long way in the two years she has been in business. It was only recently that the restaurant began advertising itself as LGBT-friendly.

She said she opened the restaurant so there is a place where people can go and there is "no discrimination against anyone" and no one is looked down on or judged.

Officials said the government is reviewing a report on the possibility of same-sex marriage and is considering new laws that would support it.

"Though the work has been slow, the government is working on the issue," said Bharat Raj Sharma of the Ministry of Women, Children and Senior Citizens. "There are many complications that need to be sorted out first."

He said the new Civil Code and the proposed citizenship bill are making the issue more complicated and they are working with other ministries to resolve them.

But activists remain unconvinced.

"Whatever is written in the constitution for sexual minorities has not been reflected in the laws and regulations that have appeared in Nepal," Dhakal said. "We are saddened by how the government and lawmakers are ignoring our plight."

DETROIT (AP) — The Oakland Athletics no longer have to wonder where they'll play the next few seasons. That won't make the long goodbye any easier.

The A's reacted to the announcement that this will be their last year in Oakland with a mixture of sadness and relief.

“At least as a player, you know where you’re headed,” outfielder Seth Brown said Friday before a game against the Tigers in Detroit. “There’s obviously a lot of moving parts, a lot of stuff we’re not privy to, so it’s just been kind of a waiting game on our end. Where are we going to go? Where are we going to be? So I think just having that knowledge -- at least we know where we’re going to be playing next year.”

Vivek Ranadivé, who owns the Triple-A Sacramento River Cats, and Oakland Athletics owner John Fisher announced Thursday that the A’s will temporarily relocate to West Sacramento's Sutter Health Park for at least three seasons. The A's are moving to Las Vegas after a new ballpark is constructed.

The River Cats, who are affiliated with the San Francisco Giants, will continue to play at the same facility.

Fisher was unable to reach an agreement with Oakland city officials on extending the lease at Oakland Coliseum, which expires at the end of this season. The A's have played in the city since 1968.

“There's direction now, which we've talked a lot about,” Oakland A's manager Mark Kotsay said. “We've got time to kind of reflect on what this really means from an organizational standpoint, the history that we've had in Oakland, with this being now the final season. There's a lot of emotion that goes behind this.”

It will not only cause some upheaval for the players and staff but also members of the organization that work behind the scenes.

“At the end of the day, we know where we're going to be for the next three seasons after the finish this year and that in itself gives a little bit of stability,” Kotsay said. “At the same time, in the present, it's challenging in certain ways to think about the finality of this organization in Oakland.”

Sacramento will be a much smaller environment to house a major league team. Ranadivé said the River Cats venue currently seats 16,000 when counting the stands, the lawn behind center field and standing room only.

First baseman Ryan Noda is concerned with the facilities. He's hopeful that significant upgrades will be made, much like the Toronto Blue Jays did at Buffalo's Triple-A facility. The Blue Jays played at Buffalo's Sahlen Field in 2020 in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“New walls, new dugouts, new locker rooms — everything they needed to become a big league stadium,” said Noda, who played some games in Sacramento as a minor leaguer. “As long as we can do something like that, then it'll be all right. But it's definitely going to be different than playing in stadiums that hold 40,000 people.”

Kotsay is confident the upgrades will occur.

“I know it will be of major league baseball quality,” he said. “It's has to be of major league baseball quality. I know the Players Association will make sure that takes place, as they did in Buffalo.”

For the rest of this season, the A's will have to deal with small home crowds and disappointed fans.

“We’re sad for the fans, the diehard fans, who always come to our games, always support us, always support the boys wearing the jersey,” Noda said.

AP MLB: https://apnews.com/hub/mlb

Sacramento Kings owner Vivek Ranadive, center, shakes hands John Fisher, owner of the Oakland Athletics, before the start of a news conference where Fisher announced his team will leave Oakland after this season and play temporarily at a minor league park, during a news conference in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4 2024.The A's announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

Sacramento Kings owner Vivek Ranadive, center, shakes hands John Fisher, owner of the Oakland Athletics, before the start of a news conference where Fisher announced his team will leave Oakland after this season and play temporarily at a minor league park, during a news conference in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4 2024.The A's announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

John Fisher, owner of the Oakland Athletics baseball team, announces that his team will leave Oakland after this season and play temporarily at a minor league park, during a news conference in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4, 2024. The A's announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

John Fisher, owner of the Oakland Athletics baseball team, announces that his team will leave Oakland after this season and play temporarily at a minor league park, during a news conference in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4, 2024. The A's announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

Sutter Health Park, home of the Triple A team Sacramento River Cats, is shown in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4, 2024. The Oakland Athletics announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

Sutter Health Park, home of the Triple A team Sacramento River Cats, is shown in West Sacramento, Calif., Thursday, April 4, 2024. The Oakland Athletics announced the decision to play at the home of the Sacramento River Cats from 2025-27 with an option for 2028 on Thursday after being unable to reach an agreement to extend their lease in Oakland during that time. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

Oakland Athletics manager Mark Kotsay walks to the dugout after making a pitching change during the eighth inning of the team's baseball game against the Cleveland Guardians in Oakland, Calif., Sunday, March 31, 2024. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)

Oakland Athletics manager Mark Kotsay walks to the dugout after making a pitching change during the eighth inning of the team's baseball game against the Cleveland Guardians in Oakland, Calif., Sunday, March 31, 2024. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)