President Donald Trump's lawyers urged a judge Wednesday to halt a lawsuit from a woman seeking Trump's DNA to help prove her claim that he raped her in the 1990s, though her lawyer offered to hold off the DNA request for a time.
Former advice columnist E. Jean Carroll is suing Trump for calling her a liar when she went public with her rape allegation last year. Trump's lawyers argue her case — including the DNA request — needs to wait until New York's highest court rules in a separate case against him. That ruling could take several months or longer.
Click to Gallery
President Donald Trump's lawyers urged a judge Wednesday to halt a lawsuit from a woman seeking Trump's DNA to help prove her claim that he raped her in the 1990s, though her lawyer offered to hold off the DNA request for a time.
Carroll, who watched from the courtroom audience, said afterward she's pursuing the suit “not just for myself but for every woman in America who's been grabbed, groped, harassed, sexually assaulted, and has spoken out and still has been disgraced, shamed or fired.”
He said he'd never met Carroll, shrugging off a 1987 photo of them and their then-spouses at a social event as simply a snapshot of a moment when he was standing in a line.
“Courts are required to give the president deference” because of his national responsibilities, said one of his lawyers, Christine Montenegro.
Carroll is seeking damages and a retraction of Trump's statements, which she says harmed her reputation and career. Elle magazine ended her contract in December, after 26 years. She said she was fired over her tangle with Trump; the magazine’s publisher told The New York Times the decision wasn’t about politics.
Judge Verna Saunders gave no indication Wednesday how or when she might rule on whether to pause Carroll's case.
E. Jean Carroll talks to reporters outside a courthouse in New York, Wednesday, March 4, 2020. As part of her defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump, Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from him in an attempt to prove he raped her in the 1990s, which Trump denies. (AP PhotoSeth Wenig)
Carroll, who watched from the courtroom audience, said afterward she's pursuing the suit “not just for myself but for every woman in America who's been grabbed, groped, harassed, sexually assaulted, and has spoken out and still has been disgraced, shamed or fired.”
Carroll says Trump assaulted her in a luxury department store dressing room in the mid-1990s, after they bumped into each other and bantered about trying on a bodysuit.
Trump said Carroll was “totally lying” to sell a memoir that was published last year, adding in one interview that “she's not my type.”
E. Jean Carroll arrives to a courtroom in New York, Wednesday, March 4, 2020. As part of her defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump, Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from him in an attempt to prove he raped her in the 1990s, which Trump denies. (AP PhotoSeth Wenig)
He said he'd never met Carroll, shrugging off a 1987 photo of them and their then-spouses at a social event as simply a snapshot of a moment when he was standing in a line.
Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from Trump to see whether it matches as-yet-unidentified male genetic material found on a dress that she says she was wearing during the alleged attack. Carroll says she hasn't laundered the dress and donned it only once since, for a photo shoot last year.
Trump’s lawyers have asked a court to put her case on hold until New York's highest court rules — in another woman's defamation case against him — whether an incumbent president can be sued in state courts over alleged conduct outside his official duties.
E. Jean Carroll, center, waits to enter a courtroom in New York, Wednesday, March 4, 2020. As part of her defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump, Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from him in an attempt to prove he raped her in the 1990s, which Trump denies. (AP PhotoSeth Wenig)
“Courts are required to give the president deference” because of his national responsibilities, said one of his lawyers, Christine Montenegro.
Carroll lawyer Roberta Kaplan offered Wednesday to postpone the DNA request and sworn pretrial questioning of Trump until after the state high court rules in the other case. But she asked the court to let other evidence-gathering continue.
Trump's lawyers rebuffed the proposal.
E. Jean Carroll, center, waits to enter a courtroom in New York, Wednesday, March 4, 2020. As part of her defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump, Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from him in an attempt to prove he raped her in the 1990s, which Trump denies. (AP PhotoSeth Wenig)
Carroll is seeking damages and a retraction of Trump's statements, which she says harmed her reputation and career. Elle magazine ended her contract in December, after 26 years. She said she was fired over her tangle with Trump; the magazine’s publisher told The New York Times the decision wasn’t about politics.
The Associated Press does not identify people who say they have been sexually assaulted unless they come forward publicly, as Carroll has done.
E. Jean Carroll, center, arrives to a courtroom in New York, Wednesday, March 4, 2020. As part of her defamation lawsuit against President Donald Trump, Carroll is seeking a DNA sample from him in an attempt to prove he raped her in the 1990s, which Trump denies. (AP PhotoSeth Wenig)