Trump appointees hear opposition to Lafayette Square fencing and gates in front of the White House

Pieces of President Donald Trump's wide-ranging Washington makeover made their next step toward approval Thursday, but not without substantial critiques of plans for permanent fencing and gates around Lafayette Square in front of the White House.

The plan pits the Secret Service and administration's concerns about presidential security against the park's historical status as an open gathering spot directly in front of the Executive Mansion, where citizens come for everything from tourist selfies to war protests or spontaneous celebrations of election results.

“People came there because they knew this was our country’s town square, where they could come to express their feelings about the direction of our nation,” Pam Fessler, a former federal employee and retired journalist, told the National Capital Planning Commission.

But the body, which this spring approved Trump's White House ballroom proposal after he razed the Executive Mansion's East Wing without authorization, accepted several versions of the proposal despite the criticisms. That sets it up for a final vote in coming months. The panel separately approved the concept for a new White House visitors security screening center on the grounds south of the Treasury Department.

The Secret Service and Trump administration, besides their security arguments, also pitched the fencing as an aesthetic necessity to replace the temporary fencing and barricades that have been erected since 2020 protests over systemic racism and police violence in America. But historic preservationists, legal advocates and residents of Washington, D.C., pushed back Thursday, saying the real solution is simply to reopen the square.

“The proposed modifications claim that a fence will preserve day-to-day openness,” said ACLU attorney Laura Follansbee. But “even when the gates are open, the very presence of a fence will send a message to the public that the park is only open by permission.”

Those planning the designs said it would be too tempting for a president or the Secret Service to simply close the gates even when there is no legitimate security threat.

“It will undoubtedly become routine to shut down the park whenever a protest or mass gathering is expected, on the grounds that it might be disruptive,” Fessler predicted.

Commission Chairman Mark Paoletta, a Trump appointee, rejected concerns about public access to the park.

“I don't think the Secret Service has any intention of shutting this park when there's peaceful protests,” Paoletta insisted. “So this idea that if there's a fence up we're losing our First Amendment rights, I don't accept. OK — time, place, manner. People can come to the park.”

It was Paoletta's first meeting as chairman. White House Counsel Will Scharf previously held the role.

The visitor screening facility drew far less controversy, with commissioners broadly agreeing that it is needed to streamline entry to the complex.

The hearing Thursday was the first time the commission took up the two ideas. Despite the critiques of the fencing proposal, the commission and the separate U.S. Commission of Fine Arts have thus far not been obstacles to Trump’s plans for the capital. The fine arts panel, which is controlled by Trump appointees, approved the visitors’ center plans at its July meeting. It heard a presentation on the Lafayette Square fencing but took no action.

Planning Commissioner Evan Cash, who is not a Trump appointee, expressed frustration Thursday that the Secret Service was pushing the Lafayette Square project only a decade after winning approval for a 13-foot security fence around the White House perimeter.

“I swallowed a lot of stuff then that I never would have swallowed if I knew that we were going to be coming back and pushing people another block away from the White House,” he said.

Paoletta countered by alluding to the multiple assassination attempts against Trump, including two during the 2024 campaign and a third this past April as he attended a Washington dinner with White House journalists. Those concerns were heightened in May after U.S. Secret Service officers fatally shot a man who opened fire near a White House security checkpoint.

But Lafayette Square fencing still would be a marked permanent change to the usual access and appearance of the grounds in front of the White House. The square last had permanent fencing in the late 1800s.

The administration’s 79-page proposal for the 8-acre (3-hectare) park calls for fencing all the way around with larger gates at the north and south entrances. Options call for either including or excluding monuments located at each of the park’s four corners.

The White House Visitor Screening Facility, meanwhile, has been viewed as a noncontroversial part of the administration's call for increased security measures.

The administration says the permanent facility, which it wants open by July 2028, would replace a series of temporary tents that have been used for years, in a bid to improve security on the White House complex and enhance the experience for visitors. The original design had it being built underground near the southern end of Sherman Park, just southeast of the White House. But consultations with other entities led to it being moved to the western edge, away from utility infrastructure.

President Donald Trump sits in the back seat of the presidential SUV as he departs the White House en route to Trump National Golf Club, Saturday, Aug. 29, 2026, in Sterling, Va. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

American flags fly at half staff in honor of Dolly Parton, Sunday, Aug. 30, 2026, at the White House in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

A U.S. Secret Service agent watches through a fence as President Donald Trump departs the White House en route to Trump National Golf Club, Sunday, Aug. 30, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Protest ribbons are tied to a fence at Lafayette Park, near the White House, Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

CORONADO, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Nov 13, 2026--

Daniel and Brunilda Zaragoza of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties are pleased to offer a Richard Requa-designed Coronado landmark with approximately 15,000 square feet and a prime location across the street from the ocean. Located at 1127 F Ave in Coronado, the estate was conceived in 1925 in the Spanish Revival style and qualifies for protection under the Mills Act.

This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20261113205001/en/

The home is set on an approximately 26,000 square foot lot, which is one of the largest in Coronado. “With the rich architectural history and the impressive scale of this property, it truly represents the upper echelon of the available listings in all of California right now,” said Daniel Zaragoza.

Along with serving as the Master Architect for the renovation/expansion of Balboa Park’s most iconic buildings, Requa designed significant architectural homes all over San Diego County, including Del Mar Castle. “This home is filled with hand crafted details that would be almost impossible to replicate. A unique engineering feat is the 7,000 square feet of underground space, which has a tension-based ceiling structure similar to the Golden Gate Bridge,” noted Daniel Zaragoza, who helped the sellers purchase the home five years ago.

The property has been extensively renovated on two separate occasions over the past 10 years. “They put a lot of time and effort into preserving the character of the home while integrating modern amenities,” Zaragoza said.

The home includes four bedrooms, six full baths and three half baths. Many of the rooms have vaulted, exposed beam ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows and doors that flow outside to a secluded pool and spa area. A covered loggia, a putting green with custom lights, and a detached guest house are just a few of the other highlights.

The expansive lower level surpasses expectations, with a two lane bowling alley, an additional family room with a wet bar, and an 18-seat movie theater. Coffered wood ceilings, hand painted detailed craftsmanship, restored hardwood floors, stained glass windows and a well-conceived landscape design add to the artistic quality.

“We have traditionally focused more on marketing our listings than ourselves. We also answer the phone when people call and don’t use an assistant for that, which is something we feel is fundamental to the services we offer our clients. Relationships are everything in this business,” added Zaragoza.

Brunilda and Daniel Zaragoza relocated from Mexico to Coronado in 1978. “Mom’s been selling real estate here for 44 years and I’ve been in business for 22. She taught me how to do things the way they have always been done, and then I brought in the digital side to the business since I was younger. I was fortunate to have attended the schools here, and it’s been wonderful to represent multiple generations of families,” said Zaragoza.

Along with using AI, Zillow and the latest technology to market listings, combined with traditional marketing, Zaragoza added that the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties brand has been integral to the success of the team: “The recognition of the brand is immediate, and positive. It’s amazing to have your name associated with it, because it’s globally recognized as elite.”

For more information or to schedule a private tour, contact Daniel Zaragoza at 619-520-0772 or via email at ZaragozaRealtors@gmail.com. Visit them on the web at www.zaragozarealtorgroup.com.

About Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties proudly supports 2,100+ sales associates in 41 offices spanning San Luis Obispo to San Diego. In 2025, our expert agents assisted in more than 6,700 client transactions for over $12.4 billion in sales volume.

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties is a wholly owned subsidiary of HomeServices of America, Inc., and a member of HSF Affiliates, LLC. BHHS and the BHHS symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate.

For more information, visit www.bhhscalifornia.com. To learn about career opportunities, visit www.bhhscalifornia.com/careers.

Coronado’s historic “Crown Jewel” at 1127 F Avenue is a magnificent 15,000-square-foot Spanish Revival estate designed by renowned architect Richard Requa in 1925. Ideally positioned directly across from the ocean, this exceptional architectural landmark is eligible for Mills Act historic preservation benefits. $39,000,000 | Coronado, CA | Listed by Daniel and Brunilda Zaragoza | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties | Photo Credit: Ryan Horner