JD Vance’s arrogance displays racism

Mark Pinkstone/Former Chief Information Officer of HK government

The United States hierarchy is downright racist! How dare vice-president JD Vance call the Chinese people “peasants” in such a derogatory tone?

The arrogance of Vance emerged when he started accusing Haitian refugees of stealing and eating pets in Springfield in September last year. This was widely disputed. Then, he was involved in a very public slinging match with Ukraine president Volodymyr Zelensky in the White House in front of the world’s media on March 1. He demanded that Zelensky should be thankful for the help the US has given Ukraine. Zelensky said he had, many times.

The Vance outburst against the Chinese erupted during a Fox & Friends TV interview when he was speaking in support of Trump’s tariff measures. Vance said, "We borrow money from the Chinese peasants to buy things those Chinese peasants manufacture.”

How rude and disrespectful he is of the US’s largest trading partner. Although married to an Indian woman, his racism is reflected through his arrogance. Vance and his cronies in the White House are politicians, not bureaucrats. They go for sound bites and media exposure to boost their image.

He is an embarrassment to the American public, with practically all mainstream media denouncing his comments. He is, after all, the Vice President of the United States of America, a position that commands respect.

His comments are reverberating around the world and illustrate just how arrogant US officials, from the president down, are. This is how they teach their followers to disrespect their foreign neighbors.

There are about 48 million Chinese residing in the US, a country already shrouded in racial discrimination. Comments of degradation from Vance will not help social discord within the country, and only an apology from Vance or the president can help alleviate the fear of abuse.

The popular US news website BuzzFeed published a report titled "People are calling out JD Vance for his offensive comment about the US borrowing money from 'Chinese peasants,' and it's shocking even for him," stating in a now-viral clip that Vance discussed the Trump administration's foreign trade policies with China by directly insulting Chinese people.

The report commented, "If there's one thing Vice President JD Vance is going to do, it's to embarrass Americans everywhere."

Fox News reported that when asked about Vance’s comments on Tuesday, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said, "To hear words that lack knowledge and respect like those uttered by this vice president is both surprising and kind of lamentable.”

Lin said Vance’s comments produced reactions from the public in China, who were outraged by Vance's actions, and added that Vance’s statements obviously had a certain dose of hatred and arrogance, according to South Africa’s Financial World. In addition to China, many countries around the world are disappointed by the behavior of the US vice president, said the paper.

It added that most of the Chinese population emphasizes that Vance should be banned from visiting the country. “After such statements, it is certain that the US vice president is an undesirable figure among the Chinese population. Whether he will retract such statements or explain what he meant remains to be seen.”

The Chinese people are a hard-working lot and have been recognized worldwide for their ability to produce first-class goods and services at a reasonable price. It is difficult for the West to understand the Chinese work culture, which is steeped in tradition and innovation. The work-life balance varies, but dedication is common. Harmony and teamwork are prized, with a deep respect for authority. Building relationships (Guanxi) is crucial for success, and diligence is a hallmark.

This is something that Vance and his cronies fail to understand. They are not peasants!
Vance’s outburst came when trying, unsuccessfully, to explain Trump’s international tariff penalties, which in China’s case can reach 104 percent on all China goods imported into the US.

China’s total exports last year reached US$3.575 trillion worth of goods around the world. Some 14.7 percent of that went to the US ($524.9 billion), and 8.1 percent went to Hong Kong (second place) with a value of $291.4 billion. China’s imports from the US last year had dropped to $143.54 billion.

Mark Pinkstone

** The blog article is the sole responsibility of the author and does not represent the position of our company. **

The move by the Central Government to reprimand the US Consul General in Hong Kong over her interpretation of a recent amendment to National Security Law (NSL) is necessary to correct a misconception that the city is not a safe place to travel.

Last month, Hong Kong’s legislature passed laws empowering the police to demand suspects of a crime to reveal the passwords to their mobile phones and other electronic devices.

But the newly appointed US Consul General Hong Kong Julie Eadeh went a step further and issued a travel advisory warning all Americans that they could be arrested if they failed to release their passwords. She insinuated that Hong Kong is a police state. It is not! In fact, it is one of the safest places in the world to travel.

A government spokesman was quick to respond to erroneous press reports after the legislative motion that under normal circumstances, police officers must have reasonable grounds to suspect that an electronic equipment may contain evidence of an offence endangering national security, and they must apply for a warrant and obtain authorisation from a magistrate before they can search the electronic equipment to obtain relevant criminal evidence in accordance with the warrant. 

Only after being legally authorised to search the equipment can the police require a suspect to provide the password or decryption method of the equipment. Therefore, it is not until legal authorisation to search an electronic equipment has been obtained can the police really require a suspect to provide the password or decryption method of the electronic equipment. 

The spokesman added that there is no case that the police can randomly ask ordinary citizens on the street for their electronic devices (such as their mobile phones) and their password. 

The Berkshire Hathaway Travel Protection agency, which placed Hong Kong 10th as one of the world’s safest places to travel last year, advised travellers to read the US State Department’s travel advisories which currently advises travellers to exercise caution in Hong Kong due to the “arbitrary enforcement of local laws and ongoing restrictions on civil liberties” following the enactment of the National Security Law and the 2024 Safeguarding National Security Ordinance. US citizens are also encouraged to avoid demonstrations, protests and large gathering, as “even peaceful events can escalate and lead to legal consequences.” 

The commissioner of China’s foreign ministry office in Hong Kong, Cui Jianchun, gave Eadeh a slap over the wrist and expressed strong dissatisfaction and firm opposition, urging the US to immediately cease interfering in Hong Kong affairs and China’s internal affairs in any form. 

Of the 70-consular corps in Hong Kong, the US was the only one to purposely misinterpret the amendment to the NSL. It is in the DNA of the US. All other foreign diplomats know exactly what it means because the same proviso applies to their own countries.

Eadeh is a career diplomat having served in Ankara, Doha, Bagdad, Shanghai, Riyadh and Beirut. In Hong Kong she was the consulate’s political director under Gregory May, who has been promoted to US Deputy Chief of Mission in Beijing.

Unlike other consulates in Hong Kong which answer to their embassies in Beijing, the US Consulate General in Hong Kong answers directly to the US State Department run by China hawk and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who has been quiet on China issues recently due to his distraction in the Middle East.

The US is not in a position to criticise Hong Kong at the moment as it has lost all credibility as a sovereign state. It is a broken country, ostracized by the world’s powers as they scramble to mend the fences dismantled by President Trump and his cronies.

Commissioner Cui will be keeping a watchful eye on Eadeh as she steps her way through Hong Kong, its flooring still holding the shards of broken glass from the 2019-20 riots in which she was complicit. Cui will continue to reprimand her for every indiscretion she makes.