Recently, I have seen people overseas mourning the so-called "8.31 incident" of 2019, the alleged "deaths at Prince Edward Station". In some places, they even built a joss-paper replica of Prince Edward Station in all seriousness. To mourn an utterly fictitious event with persistent remembrance rather reveals the illusoriness of this mortal world.
This brings to mind a Buddhist parable: "The Heavenly Maiden Scattering Flowers".
I recently visited the Mogao Caves in Dunhuang. In one of the grottoes, I saw the celebrated "Vimalakirti Sutra tableau". The tableau is a monumental Buddhist mural painted after the Vimalakirti Sutra. "Jingbian", or sutra tableaux, are paintings that narrate the stories of the Buddhist scriptures in pictorial form.
The tableau depicts a debate between Vimalakirti, a great lay Buddhist of Vaishali in ancient India, and Manjusri Bodhisattva. Vimalakirti's eloquence was unhindered, and many of the Buddha Sakyamuni's disciples had been bested by him in argument. So Sakyamuni sent Manjusri, foremost in wisdom, to debate Vimalakirti under the pretext of paying him a sick visit.
A side episode unfolds in the course of the debate. As the layman Vimalakirti and Manjusri Bodhisattva spar fiercely over the Dharma, the atmosphere turns sacred. A heavenly maiden dwelling in Vimalakirti's residence is moved by their Dharma discourse and reveals herself from the void in the sky above.
With her supernatural powers, she showers celestial mandarava blossoms over every bodhisattva and disciple present. Such is the origin of the saying "a heavenly maiden scattering flowers".
The flowers that fall on the bodhisattvas slip straight to the ground. But those that fall on Sariputra, a disciple of Manjusri, stick fast and cannot be shaken off. Sariputra feels that flowers clinging to a monk's body violate the precepts and look undignified. He summons his supernatural powers to brush them away, only to find that the harder he tries, the tighter they cling.
The heavenly maiden says to him: the flowers themselves have no discriminating mind. It is your own mind that discriminates, and that is why the flowers stick.
The heart of the parable lies in human fixation. The flowers never cling to anyone of their own accord. They stick only because of one's own fixation. This is the truth of "flowers linger because the mind holds on".
During the 2019 Prince Edward Station incident, certain people deliberately spread fake news online claiming that police had beaten six people to death. The protesters bought it. They kept returning to Prince Edward Station to mourn, and they clashed with the police again and again.
Later, even one of the rumored "dead" resurfaced in the United Kingdom. No amount of outside scrutiny has ever established that a single protester died at Prince Edward Station. Yet those who believe will go on believing. Many Hong Kong people now in exile overseas remain obstinately fixated to the "deaths" at the station.
Even on this year's August 31, people were still setting up altars in Vancouver, Canada and elsewhere to mourn the so-called "8.31 incident".
This is fixation. It means clinging to something that never happened. It means insisting that the police committed murder most foul, that Hong Kong is a place of utter terror, and that the only choice was to flee Hong Kong and emigrate overseas.
Even after emigrating, they still can't let it go. Seven years on, they're still crawling out of the woodwork to mourn. A textbook case of much ado about nothing.
The supporters of the 2019 Black Riots chose to emigrate and start over. That was their choice. They should have settled in and begun new lives as good foreigners.
Yet they still cannot put behind them this fabricated episode from Hong Kong. It haunts them like the flowers stuck to Sariputra's body. Those flowers were illusory all along. But the moment you insist they exist, muttering endlessly that flowers clinging to you are a calamity, they will cling to you forever.
The world will not change for their obsessions. But their own lives are ruined by them.
Lo Wing-hung
Bastille Commentary
** 博客文章文責自負,不代表本公司立場 **
Eighty-one years on, a three-power summit worthy of comparison with the Yalta Conference has convened.
Going in, most people dismissed it as little more than a stunt staged to accommodate US President Donald Trump. But the cards President Xi Jinping played carried some genuine novelty.
A Modern-Day Yalta
Pre-summit analysis framed the meeting in stark terms. Those with a seat at the table had made their standing plain; while Japan, the European Union and India, left without one, were naturally sour.
And as the famous line from the US Democratic administration of those years put it, those who cannot get a seat at the dining table may well end up on the menu.
Three Leaders, Three Agendas
Vladimir Putin knows exactly where he stands. Taking his seat at this table, the Russian president will feel very much like the last guest invited to the feast. More than four years of war in Ukraine have bled Russia badly. Were it not for his good friend Donald Trump in the White House, Putin would not even dream of sitting at the great-power table.
Just showing up already burnishes his status. And if he can win further relief from US energy sanctions, it would be like scooping the pot with a losing hand. He would be grinning from ear to ear. Make no mistake: Putin's demands will be modest.
Donald Trump, the driving force behind the three-power summit, has a simple calculus. His term runs out in two years, he is already 80, and he wants his name in the history books. So he is all about ceremony, staging a modern-day Yalta. One look at his substance-free speech at the APEC meeting tells you his mind is fixed on convening the summit and posing for photos.
As for the agenda, Trump mostly takes his cues from the White House team. Following the boss's line of thinking, his aides hunted for a historic topic worthy of a three-power gathering and landed on nuclear limits. After all, Washington claims daily that China is churning out nuclear warheads. Why not drag Beijing into arms-control talks?
China was never keen on a format where three powers call all the shots. It runs against Beijing's principle that all nations are equal. And Trump's plan to turn the meeting into an arms-control session, with everyone cutting nuclear weapons, makes no sense for China either.
Even by Western estimates, the imbalance is stark. The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) 2026 yearbook and the Federation of American Scientists (FAS) 2026 report put Russia at 4,400 nuclear warheads and the United States at 3,700. China has just 620.
With an arsenal far smaller than Washington's or Moscow's, why should Beijing be summoned to cut?
Still, China is a nation of propriety, and a good host defers to the guest. If the United States is set on holding a three-power summit, China will oblige. And on home ground, Beijing can even put forward some new rules of its own.
Mutual Respect, Red Lines
So President Xi played his hand at the meeting, laying out four points on how major countries should get along and hold the floor under world peace. The first: mutual respect. Xi called it the basic rule of engagement between major powers.
China, Russia and the United States each have different national conditions, and none can change the others. That reality is a product of history, and it reflects the independent choice of each country's people. The right approach, Xi said, is to respect one another, seek common ground while setting differences aside, and pursue development together.
That means respecting each other's sovereignty and territorial integrity, the social systems and development paths each country has chosen, and each side's core interests and major concerns. It means no meddling in other countries' internal affairs. On major sensitive issues touching the other side, the powers should communicate in advance, put themselves in the other's shoes and act with caution. Above all, do not cross the other side's red line.
Xi's principle takes aim at two targets. The first is Taiwan, another reminder to Washington that this is China's red line and must not be touched. The second is the system question: drop the democracy-versus-authoritarianism talk and respect each other's systems.
Turning the Nuclear Tables
Second principle: peaceful coexistence. President Xi said the 'Thucydides trap', the idea that major powers are destined for war, is no inevitability. Everything hinges on the choices the great powers make. China, Russia and the United States should be partners and friends, not rivals locked in conflict and confrontation. They should hold the bottom line of peaceful coexistence and work together to escape the 'Thucydides trap.'
The three nations are all major victors of World War II, Xi noted. That gives them a shared duty to firmly uphold the postwar international order, defend the purposes of the UN Charter and protect the hard-won fruits of that victory.
Then comes the nuclear question. Nuclear weapons, Xi said, are a 'Sword of Damocles' hanging over humanity. They should be completely banned and thoroughly destroyed, until a nuclear-weapon-free world is built. A nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. Every effort must go toward preventing it, honoring the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons and preserving global strategic stability.
With that principle, Xi turned the tables on Washington over nuclear arms limits. When the United States presses China to cut its arsenal in lockstep with Washington and Moscow, it is really trying to stop China from closing the nuclear gap.
So China raised the stakes. It called on everyone to destroy all their nuclear weapons together and go back to zero together. That is the fairest and most thorough approach. And it lifts China onto higher moral ground. After all, if everyone is grandstanding anyway, Beijing might as well outbid them all.
China also slipped in a jab at Japan. By noting that China, Russia and the United States are all major victors of World War II, Beijing left its real target unnamed but unmistakable: Japan, the defeated nation.
Win-Win, Not Decoupling
Third, stick to win-win cooperation. President Xi said the three nations have different development endowments and strong economic complementarity, so each can use its strengths to meet the others' needs.
His prescription is blunt: ditch Cold War thinking, deepen economic and trade cooperation, and link the strengths of a resource power, a manufacturing power and a consumer power. The point is to grow the shared pie and deliver wins for all, not decoupling and breaking chains.
Energy is the immediate test. With global energy security under severe strain, the three nations can step up communication and coordination to keep energy industrial and supply chains stable and open, and to protect the security and stability of the global energy market.
That formulation matters. Beijing's call to link each side's strengths would bind the three economies by function, a rarity in past diplomatic language, and it is aimed squarely at the idea in the United States of decoupling from China.
Energy gives Beijing a clean entry point against decoupling. It speaks to American public pressure to hold down oil prices while exposing a contradiction in United States policy.
The previous United States administration hit Russian energy with sweeping sanctions, and the current Trump administration has largely kept them. If Washington is going to target Russia that hard, it should not be sitting at the same table with Moscow; if it can meet without targeting Russia so much, then it should strengthen three-way energy cooperation and lift the sanctions on Russia.
China Writes the Rules
Fourth, stick to dialogue and consultation. President Xi said differences between major powers are inevitable. Without communication, suspicion spreads, and minor frictions can snowball into major conflicts.
His prescription: "the three nations should maintain regular high-level exchanges", keep dialogue channels open at every level, and build crisis communication and prevention mechanisms. The goal is fewer misjudgments, manageable differences, and frictions that never escalate.
China, Russia and the United States, he said, should keep pushing the parties to the conflict to sit down and talk, and settle their disputes through political and diplomatic means.
That one sentence, "the three nations should maintain regular high-level exchanges", leaves plenty of room for imagination. Does Xi mean to upgrade a one-off three-way summit into a standing consultation mechanism, a kind of "China-Russia-US trilateral major-power governance"?
If so, it marks a Chinese bid to break the Cold War mindset of bloc confrontation: "the US and the West vs. China and Russia."
The joint declaration from the three leaders tells the story. China seized control of the agenda, broke the US-proposed nuclear disarmament setup, and built a new path that tacitly recognizes Russian oil exports. From here on, everyone plays by China's rules.
Lo Wing-hung