The UK's wealthy are fleeing in droves. We're talking about a net outflow of 16,500 people this year – that's a record high that puts Britain at the top of the global exodus charts. When the canaries in the coal mine start flying away, you know something's seriously wrong.
But it's not just the wealthy who are having second thoughts about Britain. A mate of mine has been keeping tabs on the 160,000 Hong Kong BNO holders who've made the move to the UK, and guess what? Some are already throwing in the towel. They're quietly packing their bags and heading back to Hong Kong, unable to cope with the pressures of British life. Even those who are still hanging on are increasingly looking over their shoulders, wondering if they made the right call.
The Hong Kong exodus to Britain four years ago brought 160,000 people to the UK, but many are now struggling with the reality and returning home.
Reality Bites Hard
Even the BBC, which hasn't exactly been Hong Kong's biggest cheerleader, has cottoned on to what's happening. They've published a feature report that's pretty telling, if you ask me.
Take this bloke they interviewed – Mr. Chu. He moved to Birmingham in 2022 during the pandemic, thinking he'd build a better life. Instead, he found himself bouncing between warehouse jobs and restaurant work, battling loneliness and depression so severe he contemplated suicide. The final straw? When he tried to stop a customer from doing a runner without paying, he got beaten up. Chu called the police, yet they couldn't be bothered to show up the first time. When they finally did arrive, they took his statement, watched the CCTV footage, and then... nothing. A year later, they're still "investigating."
Social media posts reveal BNO holders are planning their return to Hong Kong after securing UK residency, citing Britain's economic struggles and poor living conditions.
That's when it hit him – why on earth was he staying? As he put it, "if people value you in a place, you can consider that place home." Clearly, Britain wasn't valuing him much.
He's not alone either. A Hong Kong social media post recently went viral, with someone pointing out that loads of BNO holders are planning to return home once they've secured their permanent residency. His verdict: "Hong Kong is truly much better than the UK." Ouch.
The Numbers Don't Lie
Let's talk brass tacks here. The economic reality is pretty stark when you actually crunch the numbers. The UK managed a measly 0.7% growth in the first quarter, with projections of just 1.1% for the full year. Meanwhile, Hong Kong posted 3.1% growth and is looking at potentially hitting 3% for the year.
But it gets worse for Britain. Higher income tax rates, yet lower professional salaries compared to Hong Kong. That's not exactly a winning combination, is it? From a purely financial standpoint, jumping ship and heading back to Hong Kong makes perfect sense.
Then there's the quality of life factor. I heard a heartbreaking story recently about an elderly woman who sold her Hong Kong property to help her daughter's family buy a place in Britain. She moved with them, thinking it would be great. Instead, she found herself miserable, clashing with her son-in-law, and spiraling into depression. Eventually, she gave up and came back to Hong Kong alone, where she's now waiting for transitional housing. Despite living by herself, she's got relatives and friends around here – and she's infinitely happier than she ever was in Britain.
Just the Beginning
Here's my prediction: these stories aren't one-offs. They're the tip of the iceberg. The "return wave" is only just getting started, and we're going to see a lot more Hong Kong BNO holders realizing that the grass isn't always greener on the other side of the pond.
The irony is delicious, really. Four years ago, we were told about this great exodus from Hong Kong to the UK. Now we're seeing the reverse migration trend that nobody wants to talk about. But when even the BBC can't ignore it anymore, you know it's real.
Lai Ting Yiu
What Say You?
** The blog article is the sole responsibility of the author and does not represent the position of our company. **
The British government runs a tight ship when it comes to managing risk. London loves stacking up benefits but dodges the downside whenever possible. After tightening permanent settlement requirements, the UK just pulled another calculated move—updating its "Foreign travel advice - Hong Kong" to clarify what Hong Kong BNO holders can't expect if they return home.
The UK just warned Hong Kong BNO holders: return home, you're on your own. London's bracing for the return tide—and dodging future headaches.
Here's the bottom line: because the HKSAR government doesn't recognize the BN(O) passport or dual nationality, Hong Kong people who moved to Britain on a BN(O) visa—or who've already naturalized—won't get help from the British Consulate-General in Hong Kong if they come back. If these Hong Kong BNO holders run into legal trouble or get detained, the consulate won't be riding to the rescue. Sharp observers say London has spotted a growing return tide and is "shutting the back door" early to avoid endless headaches down the road.
Nearly 170,000 Hong Kong people have already settled in the UK under the BN(O) visa route. Under the "5+1" pathway, many will qualify for indefinite leave to remain as early as next year. But life in Britain hasn't matched expectations for everyone. Some have already started drifting back to Hong Kong. Others are planning to grab settlement status next year, then head home to chase better paychecks.
Reality Check from London
The British government has clearly seen this trend coming. It's planning ahead—and preparing for the possibility that some Hong Kong BNO holders or naturalized citizens might get arrested after returning to Hong Kong.
The UK Foreign Office's warning spells it out: because the HKSAR government doesn't recognize dual nationality, Hong Kong people holding a BN(O) passport, permanent residency, or British citizenship will still be regarded as Chinese nationals. Result? The British Consulate-General in Hong Kong may be unable to provide consular assistance.
A friend pointed out something crucial: when the UK rolled out the BN(O) visa plan in early 2021, it carried an intention to create trouble in Hong Kong and violated the Sino-British Joint Declaration. The HKSAR government therefore stated clearly it wouldn't recognize the BN(O) passport. In that case, the British consulate in Hong Kong naturally couldn't offer assistance to such individuals—yet the UK side never made this point crystal clear.
Now the UK has updated its "Hong Kong travel advice" and laid it out explicitly. The message to returning Hong Kong BNO holders couldn't be clearer: if anything happens after you enter Hong Kong, the British consulate won't step in. Don't blame the consulate for refusing to help when the time comes, and don't expect it to shoulder any legal or moral responsibility.
The Return Tide Rises
In reality, the number of Hong Kong BNO holders returning to Hong Kong is bound to rise. From the UK government's perspective, making this clear upfront is indeed necessary—it can prevent the consulate from being dragged into trouble later.
The UK Foreign Office also suggests that if these Hong Kong people formally renounce Chinese nationality, they should carry relevant documentary proof. The implication? If a Hong Kong BNO holder in Hong Kong doesn't hold Chinese nationality, the consulate might provide assistance. But here's the thing: the overwhelming majority of Hong Kong BNO holders won't renounce their Hong Kong permanent resident status or give up their HKSAR passport just to qualify for consular help. The UK government has likely run the numbers: those willing to renounce Chinese nationality in exchange for consular assistance will be few and far between.
Politically speaking, the UK government may have also calculated something else. Among Hong Kong BNO holders returning home, some left for Britain back then out of hatred toward the government. There's a real chance they could break the law in the future. To avoid accusations later that the consulate stood by doing nothing, the UK is issuing a pre-emptive "liability waiver" statement.
Some Hong Kong BNO holders left angry, could return angrier. The consulate's closing the door before trouble knocks.
No Safety Net for Naturalized Citizens
Beyond Hong Kong BNO holders, the UK Foreign Office's advisory also targets those who've obtained permanent residency and those who've naturalized as citizens. Because the Chinese government doesn't recognize dual nationality, they're all regarded as Chinese nationals. If something happens after they return to Hong Kong, the British consulate likewise can't provide assistance.
Some Hong Kong BNO holders have already said they'll return to Hong Kong for better-paid work once they secure a settlement. That means a wave of UK "permanent residents" may head back next year. The UK is playing it smart—being "the villain first, the gentleman later"—so these returnees don't harbor unrealistic expectations.
As for Hong Kong people who've become British citizens, the number returning to Hong Kong is currently limited. Still, once the "5+1" pathway starts producing larger numbers of new citizens, the flow back to Hong Kong will increase. By stating its position in advance, the UK is telling them: if problems arise in the future, don't come "knocking on the door" of the consulate for help.
For the British government, shutting the back door to avoid trouble fits perfectly with its long-standing instinct to dodge responsibility and minimize risk.
Lai Ting-yiu
