Musk vs. Starmer: The Murder That Split the West

In December last year, 23-year-old Vickrum Digwa — a British man of Indian-Sikh origin — stabbed Henry Nowak, a 18-year-old white college student, five times on a Southampton street. Nowak died from his wounds. When police arrived, Digwa claimed he had been the victim of racial discrimination. Despite Nowak repeatedly telling officers "I've been stabbed, I can't breathe," police did not administer first aid. Instead, they handcuffed Nowak and treated him as a suspect in a racism case. He died after failing to receive timely treatment.

The killing of 18-year-old white British student Henry Nowak has sparked a war of words between Prime Minister Keir Starmer and US billionaire Elon Musk.

On June 2 this year, the court convicted Digwa of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 21 years. The court rejected both his claim of racial discrimination and his plea of self-defense.

The verdict alone would have been significant. Then police bodycam footage of the response went online, and the debate exploded. Large-scale protests and clashes erupted in Southampton, injuring 11 police officers and resulting in two arrests. Nowak's father, speaking after sentencing, said he hoped the case would make Britain's streets safer — not be weaponized to fuel "further division, hatred or tension."

The case triggered protests in Southampton, with clashes between police and demonstrators.

That plea went largely unheeded. The case galvanized Elon Musk, the right-leaning billionaire who owns the social platform X. He posted relentlessly, accusing British law enforcement of applying "double standards." On Thursday, June 4, Prime Minister Starmer hit back, accusing Musk of "interfering in British politics" and "stoking division." The two have been trading blows from afar ever since, and the controversy has yet to subside.

US Vice President J.D. Vance joined the chorus on June 5, posting on X that Nowak's death was "the same way a civilization dies: abandoned, handcuffed by authorities who neither trusted nor cared for him, and accused of hate crimes he did not commit." The UK Prime Minister's Office condemned the post as "people trying to interfere in our democracy and stir up division in our streets". 

Musk's framing has been blunt. "The West has created an utterly evil state religion where an accusation of “racism” is the gravest offense that can be committed, even worse than rape or murder!" he wrote. He added: "So if police show up at a crime scene and a British boy is bleeding out and an immigrant says the British boy is racist the cops will cuff the dying British boy..."

The Guardian reports that Musk has been posting about the Nowak murder case for weeks, with many posts drawing heavily on far-right talking points. On June 4, Starmer met Nowak's family at Downing Street to discuss the actions of Hampshire Police. After that meeting, Starmer said he was deeply saddened and angered, and vowed not to shy away from disciplinary investigations into the officers involved. He also pledged a review of race-related policing guidelines and promised to take all necessary steps to correct the mistakes made in this case.

Starmer also praised Labour MP Jess Asato, who is taking legal action against xAI — a subsidiary of Musk's SpaceX — alleging that its AI chatbot Grok helped a user generate a false, sexually suggestive image of her.

On June 2, people protested outside Southampton police station, some holding photos of the 18-year-old victim, Nowak.

Visiting York on June 4, Starmer sharpened his attack. "We need to also assert who we are as a country, because Musk, again, has been interfering in our politics in the last few days, trying to whip up division – that is not who we are in Britain," he said.

Starmer publicly denied that "double-standard policing" exists in Britain, called Musk's exploitation of the case to inflame ethnic hatred "unforgivable," and urged the public to remain rational and tolerant — and to refuse to let a tragedy be used to deepen social rifts.

The scale of Musk's intervention is striking. Over the past week, he posted more than 110 times on X about the Nowak case and British politics. With 240 million followers, Musk has used the platform to attack the British government directly and amplify anti-immigration, far-right views across the UK.

The Guardian notes that Musk frequently shares nationalist content and is a firm supporter of "Reclaim Britain" — a far-right splinter group founded by former Reform UK MP Rupert Lowe.

After police bodycam footage was released online, it ignited intense debate in the UK over policing and race.

Britain's governing Labour Party and its allies have pushed back hard. Business and Trade Secretary Peter Kyle highlighted "X and the misinformation that is spewing into the UK" in a speech late on Wednesday, and warned that a "tiny group of billionaires" are now showing a disproportionate interest in the lives of British people, including how they vote." Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood was equally direct: "There can be no justification for hijacking this tragedy to stir up violence and disorder."

Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey went further, calling the episode an organized campaign of foreign interference in British democracy, with a rogue American tech billionaire pulling the strings.

Not everyone on the right has been willing to simply condemn. Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch told the BBC on June 4 that "some are exploiting conflict to create tension in order to win votes from particular groups." She warned that while such tactics may bring short-term political gains, "in the long run it risks civil strife," and called for unity rather than division.

On June 2, the court convicted Digwa of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

Reform UK leader Nigel Farage, meanwhile, declared the Nowak murder a clear example of "two-tier policing" and urged Britons to respond with "pure cold rage," calling for an end to “culture of fear that puts minority lives on top and white ones at the bottom”. The Guardian noted that this framing — implying minorities receive more favorable treatment than white people — is a standard far-right rhetorical device.

US outlet Wired reported on June 4 that the anger generated by the Nowak case is being actively leveraged by far-right groups on both sides of the Atlantic. Social media posts have claimed that Nowak's death is proof of "antiwhite racism."

The controversy reached the level of official US government intervention on June 4, when the State Department posted condolences for Nowak's family while simultaneously criticizing Britain's "two-tiered policing". The post stated that "Ideological conditioning and two-tiered policing are glaring symptoms of civilizational decline" and "They must be rejected across the West".

UK Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Secretary David Lammy responded on Sky News on June 5. He welcomed the US government's condolences but said he "just don’t recognize” the claim that the UK has a "two-tiered policing system".

Some analysts argue that Western governments' long-standing "diversity and equality" agendas have created a political culture in which "anti-racism is prioritized above all else."

The reality is more complicated. The Guardian notes that minority communities — particularly Black communities — already face higher stop-and-search rates and harsher sentencing in Britain. A report led by Justice Secretary David Lammy found that minorities are imprisoned at significantly higher rates than white people for certain offenses, and often receive more severe sentences after conviction.

Deep Throat

** 博客文章文責自負,不代表本公司立場 **

The midterms are less than three months away. A new Financial Times poll, out August 16, shows over 53% of registered voters, among them 25% were Republicans, say their finances have worsened since Trump returned to the White House January last year.

55% disapprove of Trump's performance. Among them 20% are Republicans.

One factor is the US-Iran war and other issues that keep pushing up fuel prices and other consumer costs.

The poll also shows Democrats with a clear advantage. While 45% favor Republicans, 51% of Americans say they'll vote for a Democratic candidate in the November midterms.

On jobs and the economy, voters trust Democrats more than Republicans.

For Trump and the Republican Party, this is a blaring alarm. Republicans believe it was voter trust on these issues that powered Trump’s 2024 victory. That trust is now eroding.

The nonpartisan London-based firm Focaldata conducted the poll from August 7 to 10, surveying 1,913 registered voters.

The results are stark: 53% of registered voters say their living conditions have worsened under Trump. That includes nearly 57% of independents and almost a quarter of Republicans.

Nearly two-thirds of respondents say the US economy is on the wrong track.

53% say their living conditions have worsened under Trump. Nearly two-thirds say the economy is on the wrong track.

Trump's Approval Tanks

Voters are handing Democrats the advantage on the issues that hit kitchen tables hardest: inflation, cost of living, jobs, and the economy. It's a brutal verdict on Trump's economic stewardship.

And Trump's numbers on inflation and cost of living? Abysmal. A full 64% disapprove. That includes nearly 70% of independents and about a third of his own Republicans.

The reality is stark. US inflation hit 3.4% in July.

High prices are forcing millions of Americans to slash spending. Consumer confidence has cratered, sinking near historic lows.

And wages fell in July, according to US government data.

Trump's overall approval is just as grim. A full 55% of Americans disapprove of his performance. That includes nearly one in five Republicans.

Here's a flashing red light for the White House: Trump's net approval among Republicans (the share satisfied minus those opposed) has plunged 8 points in just one month.

Midterm Reckoning and the War Factor

Trump won't be on the ballot in November. But the midterms are widely seen as a national referendum on his leadership.

Democrats need to win just four seats in the Senate and four in the House to seize control of Congress next year.

If they pull it off, they can block any partisan legislation for the next two years. That would gut the Republican agenda, leaving it virtually powerless except through executive actions by the president and his cabinet.

According to reports, polls have been telling a consistent story for months: Democrats are likely to retake the House. The Senate? That's a tougher climb.

A string of recent polls shows Democrats could retake the House.

And then there's the war. A Reuters survey found Americans' support for a war with Iran is extremely low. The vast majority believe Trump has failed to clarify his goals or strategy.