Brazil's presidential runoff is settled. Incumbent Lula took 51.79% of the vote to beat Liberal Party candidate Flávio Bolsonaro, who finished with 48.21%. The margin was roughly 4.43 million votes, and Lula now begins a fourth term as president.
Lula Wins, Trump Cries Foul
Donald Trump is crying foul anyway. Without offering a shred of evidence, the US president questioned whether the election was "rigged." A pack of MAGA opinion leaders piled on, demanding Washington intervene and even threatening to cut diplomatic and trade ties with Brazil. A South American runoff just became a transnational political fight.
Incumbent President Lula
Trump Calls It Rigged
Trump was heading to Mississippi for a campaign rally on October 26 when reporters asked him about the Brazilian election results, according to Bloomberg and the U.S. outlet Axios. His verdict was blunt: "I didn't take sides, but it looked like another rigged election."
He added that "I just think it had a very bad look, the election, the way it was tabulated", and that the election results must be indisputable. Trump also took aim at Brazil's decision to extend voting hours, calling the arrangement "very strange" and voicing dissatisfaction with how the votes were counted.
Trump: Brazil vote looks like another rigged election
But when reporters pressed him on whether the United States would take concrete action, Trump dodged the question. He said only that he gets along with Brazil's Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva "very well."
Bolsonaro Camp Refuses to Concede
Flávio Bolsonaro is the son of former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, who kept close ties with Trump while in office. Trump once hosted Flávio Bolsonaro at the White House and publicly sang his praises.
Facing defeat, Flávio Bolsonaro at first refused to concede. He claimed Brazil's judicial authorities changed the rules during voting and demanded the election be declared invalid.
The claim spread fast. Some in the U.S. MAGA camp picked it up, forming a chorus of voices questioning the Brazilian election results.
Flávio Bolsonaro, son of ex-President Jair Bolsonaro
Bannon Demands US Action
Steve Bannon, Trump's former chief strategist, used his "War Room" program to demand that the Trump administration cut diplomatic and trade ties with Brazil. He also pressed Trump and US Secretary of State Rubio to act.
Bannon went further, tying Brazil's election to the upcoming US midterm elections. If the United States does nothing, he warned, "the same thing will happen in America next Tuesday."
The US midterm elections are set for November 3, and Republicans are heading into them with the wind against them. Bannon's message is unmistakable: treat Brazil as a warning of what could come next.
Flávio Bolsonaro initially refused to concede defeat
Right-Wing Voices Pile On
The doubt is spreading through the American right. Right-wing commentator Jack Posobiec questioned Brazil's election results on X, claiming the Brazilian left is rigging the vote "in broad daylight." He then asked whether Americans think the same thing can't happen at home.
Conservative podcast host Benny Johnson said the numbers in Brazil's election results "simply don't add up." Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier went further, calling Brazil a "banana republic" on air.
Musk Joins the Doubters
Andrew Kolvet, producer of "The Charlie Kirk Show," pushed for a more direct approach. He demanded that the US government pressure Brazil behind closed doors to reject the election results. He also called on Flávio Bolsonaro's supporters to stop working and take to the streets.
American billionaire Elon Musk joined the doubters too. He reposted a post on X comparing the vote totals from the two rounds of Brazil's presidential election. The post argued that the number of votes Lula gained in the second round made no sense, and Musk added his own verdict: "The math doesn't add up."
The Math Behind the Votes
But those calculations leave out the mechanics of the runoff. They ignore the drop in abstentions, the fall in blank and invalid ballots, and the votes that flowed over from other candidates.
Brazilian outlet UOL checked the numbers. Of the extra valid votes in the second round, roughly 3 million came from fewer people staying home, and another 1.8 million came from fewer blank and spoiled ballots.
Trump and his backers also point the finger at Brazil's decision to extend voting hours. Yet reports by Folha de S.Paulo and UOL show both campaigns asked for more time that day.
The Lula camp wanted a nationwide extension. The Flávio Bolsonaro camp cited severe weather and asked to extend voting only in selected areas.
Reuters reports that fewer than 35,000 people actually cast ballots during the extended voting window. That is a rounding error next to Lula's lead of roughly 4.43 million votes. Neither Trump nor his supporters have produced any evidence of election fraud.
Bolsonaro Pivots to Litigation
After his defeat, Flávio Bolsonaro turned around and blamed the decision to extend voting hours for tainting the fairness of the election.
According to a Folha de S.Paulo report on the 26th, allies and lawyers talked him out of his original plan to petition directly for annulment of the results.
Instead, Flávio Bolsonaro now accuses the Lula camp of abusing political and economic power. He is trying to use litigation to strip Lula and Vice President Alckmin of their election wins.
He claims Lula used public funds to buy votes during the campaign. The problem? He has not produced material that comes close to proving it.
Alckmin Fires Back
Brazilian Vice President Alckmin fired back at Trump's claims. He stressed that no evidence backs them up.
Alckmin pointed to Brazil's electronic voting system and its legal safeguards. The outcome, he said, is decided entirely by the Brazilian people.
Data from Brazil's Superior Electoral Court tells its own story: Lula would have won even without the extended voting time.
Lula Vows Equal Treatment
Lula, heading into his fourth term, made one point loud and clear in his victory speech: Brazil will never accept becoming anyone's "backyard."
He said his government will not push Bolivia around, and it will not bow to the United States. Brazil, he pledged, will treat all countries as equals.
He added that from the moment the election was won, there are no longer political opponents between them.
Deep Throat
** 博客文章文責自負,不代表本公司立場 **
